Sales commission and incentives done right
Commission disputes are rarely about the percentage. They are about the edges: who gets credit when two people touched the deal, whether GST counts, whether a returned order still pays, and why last month's statement changed. A commission scheme works when those edges are written down and the system follows them every time.
This post sets out those rules, with examples, and shows how they work in TaskSync's sales commission, part of the Sales CRM add-on. Commission there is worked out on store orders in the E-commerce operations hub, credited to agents through their leads.
Rule 1: credit follows the lead, and the lead comes first
The cleanest rule is: the agent who entered the lead gets the credit for the orders that lead places. In TaskSync, each store order gets a primary agent from its lead and an optional secondary agent, split 50/50 or by a custom percentage.
Orders are linked to leads by hand, from a quote, or by matching phone and e-mail. Then one important check: only orders from a lead entered before the order count. That stops a lead being created after the sale just to claim it.
When an order does not count, the lead-first trace shows why: the lead, the orders, the agents and shares, the commission lines, and the reason an order was left out. Most disputes end there.
Rule 2: decide the basis, and keep GST out
Commission should be worked out on the money the business actually earns from the sale. The default in TaskSync is:
- the order value without GST,
- after discounts,
- without shipping, unless you choose to include it.
Example: an order of ₹11,800 including 18% GST, with no shipping, has a basis of ₹10,000. At 3%, commission is ₹300, not ₹354.
Rule 3: payable when the money arrives
Commission on an order that is never paid is a cost with no income. So commission becomes payable when the payment is received by default. You can choose on delivery, or for marketplace orders when the payout arrives, instead. An order cancelled before it is paid is marked "Not due" and never pays.
Rule 4: returns claw back, visibly
If an order is cancelled, returned or refunded within the clawback window (30 days by default) after the commission became payable, the commission comes back as a negative line on the next statement. A part refund claws back only that part.
Example: ₹300 commission paid in October; half the order is returned in November. November's statement shows −₹150. October's statement is not reopened.
Rule 5: rules and slabs, but versioned
Simple schemes use one company-wide percentage. Others need rules by store, agent, team, channel, category, SKU or role, for example 2% on marketplace orders and 4% on your own website.
Monthly slabs come in two kinds, and it is worth being clear which you use:
- Each slice at its own rate (like income tax slabs): the first ₹2 lakh at 2%, the next ₹3 lakh at 3%.
- One rate for the whole month: cross ₹5 lakh and the whole month pays 3%.
The second is a stronger push near the threshold, and also more likely to cause arguments about one order either side of it.
Whatever you choose, every settings change is a new version. Each order uses the version in force when it was placed, so changing the rate in December never rewrites October.
Rule 6: statements with an approval step
Commission lines move from Pending to Payable, into a statement, Approved and Paid. Nothing is deleted; a later change adds an adjustment line. In TaskSync you generate statements, approve them (also through an approval chain), mark them paid with a payment reference, and export for payroll as CSV or Excel. Nobody approves their own statement.
TaskSync does not pay anyone. "Mark paid" records the payment your payroll made.
Incentives on top of commission
Commission rewards every sale. Incentives reward reaching a goal. TaskSync supports both on the same ledger:
- Target schemes pay by the slab of target reached, monthly or quarterly. For example: from 80% of target, 1% of credited sales; from 100%, 2%. Targets can be on sales, converted orders, leads won or conversion rate.
- Contests rank agents for a period and pay prizes by rank, for example ₹5,000 for first place and ₹2,500 for second.
- A leaderboard is optional. Managers get a team view, and each agent has a My incentives card.
Incentives follow the same lead-first rule and the same clawback, so a contest cannot be won with orders that come back.
Privacy
Agents see only their own figures. Managers see their reporting line, and owners and admins see everyone. If you switch the leaderboard on, agents see ranks, so decide that with the team first.
A checklist before you launch a scheme
- Write down the basis: without GST, after discounts, shipping in or out.
- Pick when it is payable: payment, delivery or payout.
- Set the clawback window to match your return window.
- Decide on split rules for secondary agents.
- Choose slab style and say it in one sentence to the team.
- Run one month in parallel with your current sheet, then switch.
For the rest of the sales side, see the Sales CRM, WhatsApp CRM and reports.